Four Brothers and a Bride

Chapter 46: Chapter 46

ASHTON

My heart rate slows down as I await her answer. I recognize the furry coat. It’s a unique piece from Ashley’s latest collection and is very pricey. I am not surprised that Demi happens to own one. Ashley is her husband after all.

However, I do find it surprising that unlike the rest of her clothes hanging carefully on the wardrobe, the jacket sits at the bottom like it was hurriedly tossed in there among her shoes. Why would she keep something so precious in there? It can’t be dirty because I haven’t seen her wear a red jacket since she joined our family. Why else would she dump it in there?

It can’t be true. The mysterious woman from my date as Will can’t be Demi. That’s ridiculous.

"Is that yours?" I repeat. My eyes wheel from the jacket to Demi’s face which is gradually beading with sweat. I want her to give me a plausible reason why her new jacket is in that state, a reason that will dispel the nasty and unpleasant feeling unfurling in my stomach. When Demi braces herself and looks at me, her eyes are not devoid of suspicion.

"It’s mine."

Why does she look so guilty right now if we are only talking about a simple red jacket in her closet? I take it that she knows why I am visibly shocked by it.

"Tell me it wasn’t you."

She cast her eyes down in a sorrowful droop and I gasp in utter shock. Edging backwards, I push open the door leading to her bedroom.

"Ashton, wait! Please! Hear me out."

With impeccable control, I pause my march outside her room. How can she possibly explain this? Even my family doesn’t know about Will! That’s how fucked up this is.

"Have you been stalking me?"

"NO!" She squeals, reaching to grab my shoulders. "No, Ashton, I didn’t stalk you."

How much does she know about me? I know she suspects my hair color but did she already know about my black hair when she found the hair gels in my bathroom cabinet? Was she pretending even then? How the fuck did she get my second contact and chat me up as Will? Was she aware it was me the whole time while we chatted? Why the fuck did she even try to go on a secret date with a stranger in a far diner without telling anyone? My mind is literally abuzz with questions right now.

"START TALKING." I order her. "From the beginning. Leave nothing out."

Demi’s lips tremble as she begins to recount her story. Apparently, she got wind of Mr. Fantasy from her cousin, Kira. I believe that bit as I recall a message from one Kira C. That must be Kira Collin.

"I promise I only went out of curiosity. I was bored and I felt like having lived with you guys for months, I’d be able to rate this stranger. I also justified it as a way to catch an impostor. I’m sorry Ashton."

I don’t believe her. I want to but there are so many holes in her story and I can feel her trying so hard not to tell the undiluted truth.

"If you meant to catch the impostor or rate this stranger’s skills of impersonation, why did you ask to go on a date with Will instead of the ’Ash Rollins’ lookalike version called Mr. Fantasy. Huh?" The question stumps her. "Answer me, Demi!"

Her eyes go misty with tears. "You wouldn’t respond to messages as Mr. Fantasy. I had no choice."

I chuckle loudly now. "You expect me to believe that?" My head is steaming now at how untruthful she’s being. "You came up with a bullshit story about having a shitty boyfriend and wanting to hang out. You followed me up for days to make sure the date happened! All for what? To rate a stranger’s impersonation skills? No!" Demi shudders at my flaring eyes and takes small steps backwards as I advance towards her.

"Here’s the truth you do not want to admit. You knew I was Mr. Fantasy long before you sent me that message. I don’t know how but that’s the only thing that makes this story add up. I don’t know why you insisted on the date only to stand me up. When I noticed you lurking by the corner, you ran away in a cab." I grab her shoulders and narrow my eyes at her. I can’t believe she can be such a mastermind.

"Who exactly are you, Demi? Why did you stalk me?" Demi only cries harder and mumbles incoherently. "You’ve been lying to me all along and pretending to be clueless about my hair and Mr. Fantasy. What other secrets are you keeping from me? Tell me, Branson!"

She wipes her tears and stares up at me. "You’re right. I wasn’t entirely truthful earlier. I’m too embarrassed to admit the truth

that would feel like. I soon realized it was going to be an uphill task convincing him to play you because he was adamant on being called Will so I made up a story just to ensure he comes out on the date.

your car. Ashton, I was scared at first thinking you’d recognize me and probably scare off my date. I waited by the corner hoping you’d get your food and leave but when

didn’t mean to lie to you or pretend about that night. I wanted to tell you but I felt that you had your personal reasons for being Will or Mr. Fantasy. I didn’t know how to bring it up. I’m

and tug. Maybe I believe her but it doesn’t ease the sting to my pride. She knows about my weakness now. How could I have

leave like this. Please,

can’t...I can’t

Her story might make some sense and maybe part of me feels glad that the random guy she was going on a date with was to satisfy the urge to have a real date with me. However,

the elevator

and Olivia." Asher’s interest

with Olivia. Ashal had deleted Olivia’s contact from her phone and from his recent search of Olivia’s phone, Demi’s contact is missing

the past. However, she hasn’t tried to communicate with Demi since the last message I deleted." Ashal confirms. "I trust her. She is trying her

ignore the surprise that flits across Asher’s face at

"Is she trying to play mind games with us? Do you think she knows anything about Olivia beyond the texts Olivia

mind reels back to the episode in Demi’s room and how she had cleverly pretended not to know anything about my secret identity. Although it breaks my heart to admit it, I won’t be surprised if Demi actually knows more about Olivia than she’s letting on. My heart

into my fearful thoughts. I am overthinking it. Demi might have lied about our date and knowing my secret identity but that doesn’t translate to her having a grudge against

my own head. "Penny for your thoughts?" My

her? Let’s start there at least. If Demi’s response doesn’t hold up with our

shakes his head. "Why waste time asking questions she’s probably going to lie about? I suggest we tap her phone, get to know who she calls and texts along with all the juicy details of her conversations. Who’s in?" Asher asks with his hand raised. Ashely and Ashal hesitate

Demi’s dishonesty come to the fore of my mind. I desperately need to know the real truth before my imaginative mind, which is dangerously teetering towards the worst, gets the best of

I join

as the rest of our

around Demi twenty-four seven. Find a way to distract

you in a long while. Love that for you. However, I’d like you to pay close attention to Olivia and ensure she tells

it." Ashal concurs with

circumstances should she

snickers. "You don’t have to tell me twice bro. None of y’all are even allowed there till further notice." While Ashley and Ashal laugh over the latter’s statement, I lock cold eyes

to give him a shot. Despite how scared he had been when she had tried dialing Asher’s number (without knowing that Ashal had swapped his contact name with Asher’s so Olivia was indeed calling Ashal and not Asher), Ashal had gleefully told us everything and

the bastard has attempted to take the lives of two people who

slowly disperses, I put a hand in Asher’s path as he tries to

Why is he still roaming the streets freely after everything he’s done?" The anger I’ve been fending off is starting to seep out as I recall Anna on her hospital bed and the red fingerprints on Demi’s

told you I’d

OVER A WEEK!" I grunt. "And he’s been going about trying to hurt more people around

else did he hurt?" At the pained look on my face, my brother’s eyes go warm with understanding.

again. She’s got

certain

run a hand over my face, stifling the urge to punch the wall. "He probably thinks Demi also knew about my visit or instigated me to attack him. It’s all my fault.

do

LOVED ONES." I yell in my brother’s face. "Someone’s got to teach him that

I’ll avenge her." Ashley whips behind me. When I turn, he has a placid look on his face that slowly morphs into a frown. "Thank you, Ashton, for your zeal to punish that fool for hurting Asher and Demi but I’d like to

what’s that?"