The Beginning Of All Sins

Chapter 59

While on their way home, Tyler received a phone call from Naomi. They were still holding hands, but the moment Olivia heard Naomi’s voice, she immediately withdrew her hand, as if shocked.

Tyler sensed her nervousness as she pulled away but didn’t look at her. Instead, he gazed down, recognizing her unease.

Naomi sounded cheerful on the phone, “Tyler, it’s my birthday tomorrow. I’d like to come home to celebrate, what do you say? Staying in the hospital is so dull, and I really don’t want to spend another birthday here.”

Olivia hadn’t realized that tomorrow was Naomi’s birthday. She clenched her. teeth, trying to shrink into the background as much as possible.

Tyler didn’t reach for her hand again, allowing her to sit there quietly. He replied to Naomi, “Your health might not handle it. There are many bacteria outside,

after all.”

But Naomi persisted, sounding somewhat coquettish, “Just do it for me this one time, Tyler. It’s agonizing being in the hospital. Consider it my birthday wish.”

They said to ask you.” How could he say no to that? After her plea, he agreed, “Alright, I’ll make the arrangements.”

decision. “Great, thank you, Tyler.” She continued chatting for a bit before they hung

then glanced at Olivia, who was

“I–Is it

replied softly, “Yes.”

I forgot.” In truth, it wasn’t that she had forgotten. They hadn’t

gift,” she mumbled

they had held hands earlier now felt like an

silent, offering

following day, Olivia headed to the mall in

wasn’t quite sure what to get her but ultimately settled on

she received a call from Naomi, who asked her to come home. Naomi was dressing up and couldn’t decide what to wear. She wanted Olivia’s opinion.

two elegant gowns in red and white. Despite the sophistication of

asked, “Should I