Unspoken Pleasure by Erotica

It's Only Fair: EP4

"I got a glance at your back for, like, a second and a half. You've been staring at me mostly naked for the past ten minutes," I said, gesturing at my outfit, or my lack of one for the most part. My erection bobbed slightly under my boxer briefs, as if agreeing. "An exchange would only be fair."

"So, you'll do it, but only if your sisters get naked with you?" Amy asked. I noticed she said your sisters and not us. I thought back through our conversations. Everything that Amy had said and done that night. Had I read the room wrong? Were the odds already in my favor? There was only one way to find out for sure. I had to bluff.

"I think we should all walk out of here now," I said, "You can be satisfied that you humiliated me, and I can be well and chastised. I've learned my lesson and I won't stare at any of you anymore." "Pssshhhhh. I'll believe that when I see it," Amy said, "You're not getting out of this that easy." Oh God fucking yes!

"If you won't leave, then we all have to get naked together," I said, the confidence practically radiating off me. Amy had told me everything I needed to know and now? This was going to be fun.

"I don't see how that's even remotely fair," Jenna said. Brianna agreed. But Amy didn't say anything. The twins both looked up at their older sister, waiting for her to shoot me down. The tall blonde stood there, thoughtful. "Amy?" the twins gasped at once.

"Who goes first?" Amy asked.

"Amy!" the twins shouted.

"Girls first, like before," I said.

"No," Amy said.

My older sister shook her head firmly. Jenna and Brianna let out a deep sigh of relief.

I did my best to hide my disappointment. They were my sisters, yes, but I couldn't help yearning to see those three painfully attractive women get totally naked. And I really thought that Amy was on my side for some reason. So why not take a shot? After all, fortune favors the horny. Or something like that.

But I'd misread the whole situation. I'd reached too far and now the opportunity was lost. I'd be thinking about those girls in their underwear for a long time. And wondering how I'd missed out on seeing so much more. "I understand," I said, unable to hide the sadness in my voice.

"We should all take off our clothes at the same time," Amy said, "Agreed?"

Hell YES we were agreed!

Jenna and Brianna both glared at their older sister like this was a game of Risk and they'd just been betrayed. I, on the other hand, felt like I could light the whole room with my happiness. I was about to see my sisters' Kamchatkas. Or at least some excellent titties.

This time, it was Jenna and Brianna who pulled Amy out of the room. They dragged her along like a kid throwing a tantrum in a toy store.

"We're not doing it, Amy," Jenna said as soon as they closed the door behind them, "I'm not getting naked in front of my big brother." "There's no way," Brianna said.

Amy said, "You can't tell me you don't want to see your brother's... His

to see it so bad,

has to be all of us or none of us," Amy said, "That's the only way it works. To punish him,

all," Jenna said, "Unless the plan

a long

before. I bet Chase hasn't

that big a

spirit," Amy said, "I mean, you've already seen so much already. And

said it was

I can hear

Silence.

watching them all over again. Jenna's lithe little body. Brianna's wide hips

big sister? She

for uninterrupted enjoyment. The next chapter is just a click away, exclusively

my one. So, each of us can take one thing off. You girls won't have to be completely naked, but I will. We each get something, but no one

our bras and you would remove your boxers?"

don't know,"

fair enough to me," Amy said, "In fact,

black lace fell away. Amy's amazing breasts sprung free. Bare, perky and beautiful. Tear-drop-shaped with little, erect pink nubs. You couldn't sculpt a pair that

The twins just stared back. There was

undershirt off. My little sister's massive tits spilled out. It was impossible to imagine how, but that thin white cami had actually been holding Bree's boobies back a bit. Where Amy had grapefruits, Brianna had

blonde hair behind her ear and looked away

Bree," Amy

too bad, are they?" Brianna asked. Her cheeks were almost as pink

joking?" Jenna asked, now staring down

said, "Seriously." I was in a tough spot. I wanted to hoot and holler. To cheer in celebration of all this incredible boob-age. Of course, I knew if I acted like that, this whole thing was over. But

more. "Thanks, Chase," she said and smiled at

and Amy were topless and looking over at Jenna. She

small, though certainly not non-existent. Her plums only looked petite next to her sisters' more

Brianna reached over and tweaked Jenna's nipple