Unspoken Pleasure by Erotica

It's Only Fair: EP25

"Well, I think Chase should take a turn," Amy said.

"Jenna had to show off to the pizza guy, I think Brianna should, too," I said.

"No more calling delivery people," Amy said.

"What if we needed to borrow something from next door," I said, "Like some AA batteries. You know. For a toy."

Amy's smile grew with every word I said. Jenna, too, looked really excited. Brianna, however, did not seem so pleased by the idea. "I don't know, guys," she said.

"If you don't do the dare, you have to strip naked for the rest of the day," Amy said, explaining the rule like it was codified in stone.

For some reason, that was enough. Brianna stood up, reluctantly, and went up to the front door. She rested her hand on the knob, like waiting for a reprieve.

"Go to 83," Amy said, "Trust me."

"Remember, you have to explain the whole thing," I said.

Brianna groaned, but she opened the door and walked out into the hallway. It was freezing out there compared to Amy's apartment and the lights were brighter, too. It made my blonde, busty sister seem even more exposed. Brianna walked delicately down the hallway, then stopped three doors down. Amy, Jenna, and I all poked our heads around the corner like we were hunting ghosts with Scooby-Doo. The hallway echoed as Brianna rapped on the apartment door.

It opened and a tall, muscular guy answered. Even I had to admit, this was a good-looking dude. He had a thick brown beard and deep, bronzed skin. Even through his white dress shirt and dark slacks, I could see how well-built he was. "Can I help you?" he eyed my little sister warily. Brianna had nothing to be ashamed of, even in the presence of Amy's hallway hunk. After all, here was a girl with epic, gravity-defying breasts. A prominent bubble butt. Long blonde hair and deep blue eyes. She was the American, corn-fed, dictionary definition of fuckable. And she was wearing nothing but a bra and panties.

"I, ummmm, need to borrow some batteries?" Brianna said. The man stared back at her. He looked to be probably twice Bree's age, but that didn't keep him from eye-fucking her from top to bottom. Brianna kept rambling, the words clearly only making things worse. "You see, I have this toy? You know a, ummm, a toy. For me. And, well, it ran out of power, and I, ummmm, I need it. So bad."

"Batteries," the man said, "For your toy."

"Uh huh," Brianna said. She started twirling her hair. Her feet were planted, but I could tell she was tensing, getting ready to run.

"Hang on," the man said. He stepped behind the door frame. Jenna started to giggle loudly, and Amy gave her a hard shove back into the apartment. That only made Jenna laugh more. Brianna was almost as pink as her sister, standing there in the hall. She kept shifting her weight from one leg to the other. She turned and stared back at us.

"He's so hot!" she whispered. She must have seen my face fall because she immediately started backtracking. "I mean, he's not... That is. You know I only..."

"Here you go," the man said. Brianna whipped her head around. The man was standing there, holding a pair of batteries in his palm.

"Double-Ds?" he asked.

nearly fell over

man said, "Is that

one of them popping right out of her bra. She finally reached the door, panting. Amy quickly pulled Brianna inside

was amazing," Jenna said. Brianna held up

calmed down, then rolled over onto their backs. Amy was standing over them,

pretty mean thing you did to your brother out there,

Her giant tit was still hanging out and she looked

it break your heart if you were in your underwear and Chase told you

In the moment, I mean, it didn't bother me too much. Even I could concede that Amy's neighbor was attractive. But I knew by now that rule number one of Amy's games was that you had to play along. It was

I don't know what I was thinking. I was just so nervous, and

only have

said you two have been making him feel bad all week about what

anything I said ever hurt you. You're special to

Jenna said, "I'm very sorry if I made you feel like you weren't

had trouble seeing them around my massive hard on. That had to make my sadness seem

guess I'm

much he means to you,"

I do, Chase?" Brianna

me. For the first time I realized what Amy had been trying to tell me. This whole time I'd truly believed my sisters were upset about what had happened the weekend before. But the looks in Brianna and Jenna's eyes

conveyed a singular emotion:

now, praying that I'd finally give them the excuse to bend over and take my dick.

sure what would fix it," I

so sexy," Brianna

brown-haired little sister stood up and started

felt my orgasm right on the edge. I had three attractive young women in only their underwear and now two of them were rubbing me. It was a miracle

hand on my cock and began lightly corkscrewing it. Jenna licked her lips. She knelt back down and put her hand on top of her sisters'. Amy gave

said, "So I could tell what

just know, you know,"

micropenis," Brianna said, "Nothing

She pulled my boxers down around my ankles. My incredible, edible erection popped out. In a second, in a fraction of a second, Brianna's mouth was around my member. She sucked it in with vigor, with passion, like it was the best

turns licking me. Both girls lollied at my pop, one by one. All I could do was stand there and groan. I could barely do that. Those girls had miracle mouths and I was